
I listened to more discussion of Prime Minister Harper's comments about certain Muslim women wanting to wear the niqab to be sworn in as citizens of Canada and his opposition to this, despite a Supreme Court ruling. A niqab is the facial covering, the burka covers the entire body, and the hijab is the head covering which often extends to the chest -- go all that?
I must admit that I have mixed feeling about this. I also wonder about Mr. Harper's motives.
I strongly believe in religious freedom, but I have listened to Muslim women argue eloquently that the niqab is a cultural practice, not a religious requirement. Others agree that it is not a requirement but women should have the freedom of choice.
There is a woman in our congregation who married a Muslim man who insisted that she wear certain clothing, and she eventually realized that this was an issue of control, not religion. I just can't accept this. At the same time, some Muslim women embrace what many of us might consider oppressive clothing and we allow it in our society. If it is not against the law to dress this way in public in Canada, why would we insist that a woman cannot wear this garb when she becomes a citizen?
As for Mr. Harper, why is he making such an issue of this as Prime Minister, addressing the issue himself rather than through a minister? Is this a political ploy, one designed to appeal to our growing fears about extremist Muslims?
When I drive up Bathurst St. in Toronto on a Saturday morning I see some Jewish men heading to synagogue wearing yarmulkes and others wearing the severe and even strange looking (to me) clothing of Orthodox Judaism. That is their right in this country. There are Sikhs who are members of parliament who wear turbans and beards. Sikhs are allowed to wear their turbans in the RCMP.

I am getting a kick out of those on Twitter who are mocking the PM's style advice. One dad asks whether he needs to consult Harper's office when his daughter covers her face.
My gut feeling is that the niqab is not necessary and doesn't reflect the freedoms of our pluralistic society. But my "sober second thought" response is, let it go Prime Minister Harper.
Your thoughts?































