Closing a Cathedral of Creativity

 

During this past weekend thousands of people congregated at the McMichael Gallery in Kleinberg, Ontario, perhaps the greatest collection of Canadian art. I use "congregated" intentionally and I might have described the gallery as a shrine or even a cathedral or artistic expression. 

Not surprisingly folk wanted a last opportunity to experience the McMichael before it closes for three years to facilitate a major redevelopment and expansion. When I read about this it was as though I was being told that a cherished church was being closed, albeit temporarily. At our age three years can bring significant life-changing events, as we constantly see with our contemporaries. I suppose what I am feeling is grief, in a way. 

We visit the McMichael at least once a year, sometimes twice or thrice, depending on the exhibitions. I first visited the gallery in the 1960s, shortly after the McMichaels gave their expansive log home and impressive collection of art, mostly Group of Seven and Tom Thomson paintings, to the Ontario government to be used in perpetuity as a museum. I've written about having my photo taken as a boy with AY Jackson, one of those painters who was living there at the time who would sit in a sunny nook. 

 The collection has expanded over the decades and many of the exhibits now bring in well curated works by Aboriginal artists and contemporary creators from other cultures as well as offering retrospectives of women who were largely ignored in previous eras. An exhibition at the McMichael introduced us to the work of Christi Belcourt, a contemporary Metis artist. 

Over time the McMichael has been expanded and refurbished but this is unprecedented. Closing for three years seems a huge price to pay for those who value time there so deeply. I know that this decision wasn't taken lightly and I pray that the project doesn't extend beyond the timeline. 

Sarah Milroy, the executive director and chief curator speaks of the 'sacred trust" the gallery represents and this an apt description. I so often have experienced a sense of the holy in art galleries and museums. Creativity in its many forms, including music, is, for me, a reflection of the Creator. 

Seeing Red

 

It's ben fun to introduce our four grandchildren to some of the cartoons and kids series of our past, although the violence and sexism of the usually clever Looney Tunes and others is an eye-opener.

Ruth found the original Anne of Green Gables series with Megan Follows and it didn't go well with our six-year-old grandchild. He is one of two redheads amongst the four, a persistent trait in the family, including Ruth, especially when she was pregnant and the hormones deepened her usually strawberry blonde hair. He was alarmed by the prejudice against Anne's ginger locks by adults and children. 

You may recall that schoolmate Gilbert called Anne "carrot" and it wasn't a term of endearment. Of course Anne was fiery in her response to her tormentor, an emotional stereotype of redheads. Yet Anne bemoaned her "life-long sorrow" and claimed she could never be happy with red hair. She managed to dye her hair green in an attempt to free herself from the curse and had her locks shorn as a result.

The shock of all this was so deep for our grandchild that they had to stop watching, immediately. He has yet to experience this in life and so was unsettled at the prospect. But maybe this silly prejudice has come to an end. 

                                                       Mary Magdalene  --Andrea Solario 1495-1524 

You may be aware that Mary Magdalene was maligned as a "wanton woman" for centuries in the church even though this is not supported by the gospels and often portrayed with red hair. 

That's the way with stereotypes and prejudices, isn't it?  Humans categorize others according to race, creed, colour and gender and it continues to be a powerful tool for control. We see it south of the border right now and it's certainly a grim aspect of our Canadian history. I grew up knowing little about other religions but Muslims were definitely not to be trusted. Aboriginal spirituality was pagan.  Homosexuals were considered an abomination and some people protested the use of the word "gay" because it was too positive, although calling someone gay was a slur. Dumb? Yup. 

I'm not a fan of the doctrine of original sin although I've concluded that hatred seems to be bred in the bone. Some say that we learn our prejudices, which is probably true, but we take to them readily. 

As Jesus-followers we can follow his example in creating a welcoming and loving environment for all rather than weaponizing our faith for exclusion. We can repent of our sins of prejudice and embrace the way of love. This shouldn't be so difficult. 

It's encouraging to see in recent years the embrace of gingerness with a growing number of gatherings and even multi-day festivals. Why not "say it loud, say it proud"? 

Neil Young and Mother Earth

                                                         1990 Promotional Poster 

[Verse 1]
Oh, Mother Earth with your fields of green
Once more laid down by the hungry hand
How long can you give and not receive?
And feed this world ruled by greed
And feed this world ruled by greed

[Verse 2]
Oh, ball of fire in the summer sky
Your healing light, your parade of days
Are they betrayed by the men of power
Who hold this world in their changing hands
They hold the world in their changing hands

[Guitar Solo]

[Verse 3]
Oh, freedom land, can you let this go?
Down to the streets where the numbers grow
Respect Mother Earth and Her giving ways
Or trade away our children's days
Or trade away our children's days

[Outro]
Respect Mother Earth and Her healing ways
Or trade away our children's days

I did not know that way back in 1990 Neil Young, rock music legend, environmentalist, and general curmudgeon wrote a song for his "mother", Planet Earth. It is called Mother Earth: Natural Anthem. I came upon a video of a live version with Crazy Horse, his band at the time. It starts out with some gritty distortion but settles into a ballad, a lament for what Christians term Creation. 

The tune had the feel of a hymn and as I listened it sounded a lot like a traditional hymn I couldn't quite conjure up. Finally I realized that the melody was O Waly Waly, or a close facsimile. In the United Church hymn resource Voices United there are several hymns using this tune including the familiar Though I May Speak. 

There is another, O Blessed Spring, that I can't recall singing but I like the earthy and seasonal lyrics. Am I correct about the Neil Young tune or am I imagining things? 

1 O blessed spring, where Word and sign

embrace us into Christ the Vine,

here Christ enjoins each one to be

a branch of this lifegiving tree.

2 Through summer heat of youthful years,

uncertain faith, rebellious tears,

sustained by Christ's infusing rain,

the boughs will shout for joy again.

3 Christ, holy Vine, Christ, living Tree,

be praised for this blessed mystery:

that Word and water thus revive

and join us to your Tree of Life.

4 When autumn cools and youth is cold,

when limbs their heavy harvest hold,

then through us warm the Christ will move

with gifts of beauty, wisdom, love.

5 As winter comes, as winters must,

we breathe our last, return to dust;

still held in Christ, our souls take wing

and trust the promise of the spring.

                                                               Neil Young Love Earth Tour 

Perfect Love Casts Out Fear

 

God is love, and those who abide in love abide in God, and God abides in them.  

Love has been perfected among us in this: that we may have boldness on the day of judgment, because as he is, so are we in this world.  

There is no fear in love, but perfect love casts out fear; for fear has to do with punishment, and whoever fears has not reached perfection in love.  We love because he first loved us. 

        1 John 4: 16-19 NRSVue

Don't be afraid, my love is stronger, my love is stronger than your fear.

Don't be afraid, my love is stronger 

and I have promised, promised to be always near. 

        More Voices 90 

I have the mute button ready when the Ontario Government indoctrination TV commercials begin during the evening news cast. Last year our incompetent and morally bankrupt  provincial government spent more than $100 million of taxpayers money pumping its own tires, a practice the Auditor General has declared as sketchy, at best, and maybe illegal.  Many of them such as the Ring of Fire commercials are deliberately misleading, touting initiatives that are actually decades away. 

The commercial that I find reprehensible at the moment is the A Safer Ontario ad which claims that: Ontario is working to protect our neighbourhoods by tackling auto theft, clearing encampments, shutting down drug injection sites near schools and daycares, building more jails and strengthening the bail system, so criminals stay behind bars.

There is no explanation of whether affordable housing is provided for those who are "living rough" or if closing down safe injection sites may actually create more risk or whether warehousing criminals does make us safer in the long run or whether denying bail will pass the legal test. These are simplistic promises based on anxiety and fear. 

There is statistical evidence that crime rates are dropping across the province and the number of murders in Toronto continues to fall. Yet we're encouraged to feel scared about our society and that Daddy Dougie will protect us. If things are so bad  just what has he been doing for the past eight years? 

It's not as though there are no concerns for public safety  -- there always are -- and we want a functioning and secure society. It's the fearmongering that is so troubling. How about using some of the $100+ million for solutions for the unhoused? 

There are many biblical verses in Older and New Testaments which encourage us to live beyond our fears with the promise that God, in Christ, is our companion in even our darkest moments. Jesus is my Saviour, not Premier Ford. 

Emancipation Day & the United Church

 

Today, August 1 is Emancipation Day in Canada. I've written about this important opportunity for reflection and hope a number of times. This year I'll share the message from the Right Reverend Dr. Kimberly Heath, Moderator of the United Church: 

[Emancipation Day] is a day to remember, to reflect, and to honour the resilience, strength, and contributions of people of African descent whose lives and communities were forever shaped by centuries of enslavement. 

For more than 400 years, millions of African peoples were captured, forced to migrate, and subjected to horrific treatment under the transatlantic slave trade system. Families were separated. Languages, cultures, and identities were targeted for erasure. More than 15 million people of African descent were affected. This horrific system resulted in the deaths, torture, and abuse of Black peoples, and has had intergenerational effects. 

The impacts of enslavement were not limited to distant places or distant history. 

People were enslaved in what is now Canada. While enslavement was legally abolished across the British Empire on August 1, 1834, its legacy did not end there. The legacies of enslavement are directly linked to anti-Black racism today. 

Emancipation Day invites truth-telling about that history and the current realities of racial injustices. 

As a church, we are called not only to remember the past but also to respond in the present. 

At the most recent General Council, the United Church also took an important action by committing to a process that may lead to a formal apology for the church's historic connections to enslavement. A working group has begun this work and will bring recommendations to the next General Council in 2028. This reflects a growing understanding that truth-telling, accountability, and repair are essential parts of reconciliation and justice. An apology is not the end of the story. But it is part of a process of repair and healing. 

The United Church of Canada has also committed to engaging with the United Nations’ Second International Decade for People of African Descent, joining a global commitment to recognize the themes of justice, recognition, and development and to continue to confront anti-Black racism. 

A history of enslavement is also not the only part of the story for Black peoples in Canada. Emancipation Day can also be a day to honour the endurance, faith, leadership, and contributions of Black communities. Black people have been part of the United Church since before church Union and continue to shape The United Church of Canada through ministry, worship, scholarship, advocacy, and community and prophetic leadership. Emancipation Day can be a day to celebrate freedom now, with festivals and parades. 

On this Emancipation Day, may we re-commit to confronting anti-Black racism and historical injustices and together continue to build a church with better places of belonging for people of all identities. 

                                                                              Kimberly Heath

Lost in Translation?

 

Are you with me that there has been way too much hype for The Odyssey out there? We have seen it and I'd give it a seven out of ten but I wish the endless interviews with Christopher Nolan and the cast would go away. Yes, we get it that Nolan is a cinematic genius and Devyn Dalton, the Canadian woman stunt double for Matt Damon has the most amazing biceps he's ever seen. 

                                                 Devyn Dalton and Matt Damon

I have been enjoying the debate about the script for the film and whether it is faithful to the original. And should Telemachus be referring to Odysseus as "dad?" It's all good, say some academics, while others declare it an abomination.

One of the naysayers is Emily Wilson one of the foremost translators of The Odyssey, and the first woman to do so. She has sold about a million copies of her translation, no doubt boosted by the buzz of the film, but she has been sniffed at by some classicists for various reasons. It seems a bit much that she has written a bluntly derogatory review of the film given the fame she's gained. 

There are scholars who are Wilson fans but support the script and note that there can be no definitive translation because The Odyssey began as oral story-telling and took on different forms through generations of writing and rewriting.

This fascinates me because the same can be argued about the bible. There was an oral tradition for both the the Hebrew Scriptures and the Gospels before scribes put quill to papyrus and parchment. The early languages included Hebrew and Greek and Aramaic. For centuries only Latin received official approval and translators into vernacular languages sometimes paid with their lives. The King James Version of the English bible was for a long time the only authorized version. 

Today we have a variety of translations and paraphrases. Is there a correct one, or do they all contribute to our understanding? We can also watch a host of films and serial adaptations of biblical stories, some of them far more popular than the written word, or Word. 

In some congregations The Chosen series about the life of Jesus is watched instead of traditional bible study. I wonder if Linus reciting from Luke's Gospel in A Charlie Brown Christmas exceeds the number of people who've read the story in any translation over the past 60 years?

I figure conversations such as these, even with some academic trash-talking, is good for our minds and even our souls. 

Learning to be Brave with Bishop Budde

 

Do you remember Bishop Mariann Budde? At the January 2025 worship service in the Washington National Cathedral as part of President Trump's inauguration Bishop Budde created the most Christian of stirs in her sermon. 

Here are some excerpts from the conclusion of her message to jog your memory: 

Let me make one final plea, Mr. President. Millions have put their trust in you. And as you told the nation yesterday, you have felt the providential hand of a loving God. In the name of our God, I ask you to have mercy upon the people in our country who are scared now, 

There are gay, lesbian and transgender children in Democratic, Republican, and independent families, some who fear for their lives.

"The people who pick our crops and clean our office buildings; who labor in poultry farms and meat packing plants; who wash the dishes after we eat in restaurants and work the night shifts in hospitals, they – they may not be citizens or have the proper documentation. But the vast majority of immigrants are not criminals. They pay taxes and are good neighbors. 

I ask you to have mercy, Mr. President, on those in our communities whose children fear that their parents will be taken away. And that you help those who are fleeing war zones and persecution in their own lands to find compassion and welcome here. Our God teaches us that we are to be merciful to the stranger, for we were all once strangers in this land. 

It will come as no surprise that Trump publicly panned this invitation to be merciful and he certainly hasn't been during these past 18 months which feel like 18 years of cruelty and terror. At the time one Republican Flying Monkey suggested that Budde be deported. 

 I think the theme of the upcoming webinar with Bishop Budde offered through Sojourners Magazine is perfect: Learning to be brave. We hear that ICE is stepping up its evil deportation program and innocent people are being killed. It feels as though bravery is being trumped by organized hatred.

I have preregistered for the webinar and I look forward to what Bishop Budde has to offer.